• 1 Post
  • 118 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 31st, 2023

help-circle

  • Look, I get that, nobody wants bloodshed for bloodshed’s sake. But this is war, they are being attacked, there are troops massing near them while they’re getting bombed. Either they get brutally murdered, or they defend themselves. That or the US retreats; I think we both know that’s not happening.

    The conclusion seems fairly simple to me.

    And tbf I’m not particularly giving much worth to those who follow orders on the US & israeli side. They made their bed, they lie in it. You can’t expect to go and kill brown people for decades, sign up to be the next generation of that machine, and come out unscathed.


  • You really ought to rethink your angle. Beyond “whataboutism” which is a useful tool to avoid any self reflection, do you really think we should first pay attention to protests, while Iran is getting bombed, i.e. every Iranian, including protesters, is in grave danger of death?

    You’re telling us we should disregard deadly danger to all Iranians and instead pay attention to some danger to some Iranians?

    To wrap this up, YOU are asking “what about the protests”; nothing in this post is about the protests. YOU are guilty of that nonsensical “whataboutism” pseudo-fallacy.

    Edit: Less personal attacks (sorry)







    1. The protests weren’t a wholesale denunciation of Iran’s government. There was some who protested for that, but most protested because of the result of US sanctions resulting in a devastating degradation of Iranian people’s quality of life.
    2. The protests and their supporters were mostly in urban centers, which the US and Israel hit. Anti-government sentiment was annihilated the instant they were attacked (or became so low on anyone’s priority that it’s functionally the same).
    3. US and Israeli bombs don’t magically spare protesters ⁉️⁉️ Like, what could possibly go in your head when hearing that Iran is defending itself, to conclude that it’s bad for Iranian people? The best thing for Iranian protesters is that Iran wins unequivocally

    Your weak ass defense of the US would be ridiculous if Iraq didn’t happen; the fact that you’re unable to learn from it is sobering. Iraqis being freed was one of the reasons given back then; as a reminder more than a million Iraqis died to it.

    Do you think Iraqi protesters were spared?



  • Because the dollar being the reserve currency is a direct result of the US being the world hegemon. As the US is falling, and China is expanding trade but not asserting itself as the hegemon, the world is becoming multipolar.

    The EU’s economic situation doesn’t allow it to become the new hegemon either, and their political fragmentation makes them unreliable anyway.

    The concept of a reserve currency might be outdated because of that multipolar world. And if not, the EU is in no position to impose the euro, as China is way more stable and has much better economic relations with everyone, including both US economic allies and enemies.

    There would be no contest if China tried to assert the RMB as a world reserve currency, but AFAIK they’re not interested in doing that.