I’m pretty sure big tech already had access to all of your pictures, and I don’t think this means the UK government will gain access, they don’t even know what to do with it anyway.
I mean they explicitly say it should be done in a way so that no data leaves the device.
They’re asking for something that will most likely require some server interaction, and can be modified to include more things the government doesn’t like (mostly if Farage takes power at some point). It would be insane to think this is all well and good.
Plus, I’m wondering how you do it without data leaving the device. All I can think of is an AI model that willl process every picture. You can’t compare to known hashes, b/c it’s a novel picture out of the camera. The device has to judge it somehow.
If there’s an AI model, you’ll have false positives and false negatives. And gray areas, where even reasonable humans would disagree. Since false negatives are way more legally risky, co’s will err waaaaaaaay on the side of false positives. Which will block totally innocent pics. And gender diffs in what’s socially accepted, and the AI will get that wrong a lot.
I’m pretty sure big tech already had access to all of your pictures, and I don’t think this means the UK government will gain access, they don’t even know what to do with it anyway.
I mean they explicitly say it should be done in a way so that no data leaves the device.
They’re asking for something that will most likely require some server interaction, and can be modified to include more things the government doesn’t like (mostly if Farage takes power at some point). It would be insane to think this is all well and good.
Plus, I’m wondering how you do it without data leaving the device. All I can think of is an AI model that willl process every picture. You can’t compare to known hashes, b/c it’s a novel picture out of the camera. The device has to judge it somehow.
If there’s an AI model, you’ll have false positives and false negatives. And gray areas, where even reasonable humans would disagree. Since false negatives are way more legally risky, co’s will err waaaaaaaay on the side of false positives. Which will block totally innocent pics. And gender diffs in what’s socially accepted, and the AI will get that wrong a lot.
Gonna be a mess.